Black checkmark with a sparkle and a curved line underneath on a white background.
Company

Franklin Templeton Holdings Trust

Ticker
FGDL
Sector
Industry
Report date
November 14, 2026
Valye AI Score

82

Very high visibility
Recent developments
Recent developments summary

Recent news highlights selling pressure and outflows for FGDL alongside recognition in commodity ETF rankings and analyst highlights.

Recent developments:
  • FGDL experienced significant selling pressure and was described as 'crowded with sellers' in June 2026 [N1].
  • The Fund was noted among the 5 best commodity ETFs in Q1 2025, reflecting market recognition [N2].
  • Analyst blogs highlighted FGDL alongside other gold ETFs for responsible sourcing and market relevance in early 2025 [N3].
  • FGDL was included in coverage of ETFs benefiting from gold's longest rally in four years in February 2025 [N4].
  • The Fund was recognized among the 5 best commodity ETFs of 2024, indicating sustained market interest [N5].
  • Earlier reports in 2023 noted significant ETF outflows including FGDL, signaling past liquidity challenges [N6].
Overview

Franklin Templeton Holdings Trust is a Delaware statutory trust offering the Franklin Responsibly Sourced Gold ETF (FGDL). The Fund's objective is to reflect the price performance of gold bullion, specifically gold refined under responsible sourcing standards post-2012. Shares represent fractional undivided interests in the Fund's gold holdings and are traded on NYSE Arca. The Fund operates with a Sponsor who manages expenses and administrative functions, charging a 0.15% annual fee. Shares are created and redeemed in Creation Units by Authorized Participants through delivery or receipt of gold bullion. The Fund does not operate as a traditional corporation or investment company and is not regulated as a commodity pool. The NAV is calculated daily based on LBMA Gold Price PM. The Fund's gold holdings decrease over time due to sales to cover expenses. The Fund reported net income of approximately $15.3 million for Q2 FY2027. Recent market coverage notes significant selling pressure and outflows, as well as inclusion in commodity ETF analyses.

Executive summary

Financial figures (if any) are summarized from the latest available SEC filings and are provided for informational purposes only — not financial advice. Franklin Templeton Holdings Trust operates the Franklin Responsibly Sourced Gold ETF (FGDL), which aims to track the price of responsibly sourced gold bullion less expenses. The Fund holds only gold bullion and cash, with shares representing fractional interests in the gold held. Shares are created and redeemed in large blocks by Authorized Participants. The Fund's expenses are primarily the Sponsor fee of 0.15% annually, with the Sponsor covering ordinary expenses. The Fund's NAV is calculated daily based on LBMA gold prices. Recent news highlights selling pressure and outflows for FGDL, alongside recognition in commodity ETF rankings.

Scenarios for FGDL

Bull case model:

The Fund benefits from increasing investor demand for responsibly sourced and ESG-aligned gold investments. Its low expense ratio and operational structure reduce overhead and support efficient management. The Fund's transparent valuation methodology and daily NAV calculation enhance investor confidence. Inclusion in commodity ETF rankings and analyst highlights may attract additional investor interest. The Sponsor's role in managing expenses and liquidity supports operational continuity.

Bear case model:

The Fund faces risks from fluctuations in gold prices and potential supply constraints of responsibly sourced gold bullion, which may temporarily force deviations from its sourcing policy. Selling gold bullion to cover expenses causes a gradual decline in gold represented per share, potentially impacting investor perception. The Fund's lack of traditional shareholder rights and limited voting may reduce investor influence. Market selling pressure and significant outflows noted in recent news may reflect investor concerns or shifts in sentiment.

Moat:

The Fund's moat derives from its focus on responsibly sourced gold bullion, aligning with growing investor interest in ethical sourcing and ESG considerations. Its structure as a Delaware statutory trust with limited liability and the backing of Franklin Holdings, LLC as Sponsor provides operational stability. The Fund's listing on NYSE Arca and use of recognized pricing benchmarks (LBMA Gold Price PM) support market transparency and liquidity. The Sponsor's assumption of ordinary expenses and the Fund's low expense ratio contribute to cost efficiency. However, the Fund's value is directly tied to gold prices and availability of responsibly sourced gold, which may limit differentiation from other gold ETFs.

Risks overview
Risks summary
The Fund's exposure to gold price volatility combined with potential supply constraints of responsibly sourced gold and the impact of expenses on gold holdings represent key risks to its value and investor perception.
Risks details:

• Gold Price Volatility: The Fund's value is directly linked to gold bullion prices, which can be volatile and influenced by macroeconomic factors.
• Supply Constraints: Temporary supply constraints or lack of availability of responsibly sourced gold may cause deviations from the Fund's sourcing policy.
• Expense Impact: The Fund sells gold bullion to pay expenses, leading to a gradual decline in gold represented per share over time.
• Limited Shareholder Rights: Shares do not confer traditional corporate rights or significant voting power, limiting shareholder influence.
• Market Liquidity and Outflows: Recent significant selling pressure and outflows may affect market liquidity and investor confidence.

FINAL FORECAST FOR FGDL

Final take one line
Franklin Templeton Holdings Trust's FGDL ETF offers a focused, responsibly sourced gold investment with transparent operations but faces risks from gold price volatility and supply constraints.
Final take 12 to 24 month view

Business trends: Increasing investor interest in responsibly sourced gold and ESG-aligned commodity ETFs alongside fluctuating market demand for gold-related products.
Execution milestones: Maintaining adherence to responsible sourcing policies, managing expense-related gold sales, and navigating market liquidity conditions.
Key risks: Gold price volatility, supply constraints of responsibly sourced gold, expense impact on gold holdings, limited shareholder rights, and market selling pressure.

Valye AI Visibility Research Score

Very high visibility

Visibility score reflects the breadth and consistency of available disclosure across SEC filings, recent public reporting, and baseline business context (research-only; not investment advice).

82
LLM visibility overview
LLM Visibility known facts
  • Franklin Templeton Holdings Trust is organized as a Delaware statutory trust and offers a single series, the Franklin Responsibly Sourced Gold ETF (FGDL) [S1].
  • The Fund's investment objective is to reflect the performance of the price of gold bullion less expenses, holding only gold bullion and cash [S1].
  • The Fund seeks to hold only responsibly sourced gold, defined as London Good Delivery gold bullion bars refined on or after January 1, 2012, in accordance with LBMA Responsible Gold Guidance [S1].
  • Shares represent fractional undivided beneficial interest in the Fund and are listed on NYSE Arca under the symbol FGDL [S1].
  • Shares are created and redeemed in Creation Units (blocks of 50,000 shares) by Authorized Participants in exchange for gold bullion based on NAV [S1].
  • The Fund's only ordinary recurring expense is a Sponsor fee of 0.15% annually of daily NAV; the Sponsor assumes ordinary fees and expenses including administrative and legal fees up to $500,000 per annum [S1].
  • The Fund sells gold bullion as necessary to pay expenses, causing the amount of gold represented by each share to gradually decline over time [S1].
  • The Fund is not registered as an investment company under the Investment Company Act of 1940 and is not regulated as a commodity pool under the Commodity Exchange Act [S1].
  • The Fund does not have officers, directors, or employees and is not managed like a corporation or active investment vehicle [S1].
  • The Fund's NAV is calculated daily based on the LBMA Gold Price PM, subtracting accrued expenses and liabilities [S1].
  • The Trust's fiscal year ends on March 31 [S1].
  • The Fund's shares do not have traditional corporate shareholder rights and voting rights are limited and at the Sponsor's discretion [S1].
  • Shares are held in book-entry form through DTC with no physical certificates issued [S1].
  • The Fund reported net income of $15,300,318 for the quarter ended September 30, 2026, per the latest 10-Q filing [S2].
  • Liquidity ratios and other balance sheet details are not disclosed in the latest SEC filings [S2].
  • Recent news indicates FGDL has experienced significant selling pressure and outflows in mid-2026 and earlier periods [N1][N6].
  • FGDL is recognized among commodity ETFs related to gold and has been highlighted in various market analyses and rankings for commodity ETFs in 2024 and 2025 [N2][N3][N4][N5].
Sources
Sources - Context summary

Generated 2026-11-14

Sources - Earning calls
Sources - Other context
Sources - SEC Filings
  • S1 | 2026-06-29 | 10-K
  • S2 | 2026-11-13 | 10-Q
Sources - News headlines
  • N1 | 2026-06-10 | www.nasdaq.com | FGDL Crowded With Sellers | https://www.nasdaq.com/articles/fgdl-crowded-sellers
  • N2 | 2025-04-02 | www.nasdaq.com | 5 Best Commodity ETFs of Q1 | https://www.nasdaq.com/articles/5-best-commodity-etfs-q1
  • N3 | 2025-02-27 | www.nasdaq.com | The Zacks Analyst Blog Highlights Franklin Responsibly Sourced Gold ETF, VanEck Merk Gold Trust, GraniteShares Gold Trust, iShares Gold Trust and iShares Gold Trust Micro | https://www.nasdaq.com/articles/zacks-analyst-blog-highlights-franklin-responsibly-sourced-gold-etf-vaneck-merk-gold-trust
  • N4 | 2025-02-26 | www.nasdaq.com | 5 ETFs Riding on Gold's Longest Rally in Four Years | https://www.nasdaq.com/articles/5-etfs-riding-golds-longest-rally-four-years
  • N5 | 2025-01-06 | www.nasdaq.com | 5 Best Commodity ETFs of 2024 | https://www.nasdaq.com/articles/5-best-commodity-etfs-2024
  • N6 | 2023-07-18 | www.nasdaq.com | SOXL, FGDL: Big ETF Outflows | https://www.nasdaq.com/articles/soxl-fgdl:-big-etf-outflows
Important legal disclaimer

This material is for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment, financial, legal or tax advice, or an offer or solicitation to buy or sell any security. The Valye AI Score is a model-based estimate derived from public information and is subject to change without notice. No representation or warranty, express or implied, is made as to the accuracy, completeness or fairness of the information herein. Past performance is not indicative of future results. Investors should conduct their own research and consult a qualified financial adviser before making any investment decisions.

Blue logo with a stylized checkmark and star above the blue text 'VALYE' on a black background.

Generated by Valye SEC Pipeline Engine